The Best Dog Treat Cookie Cutters For Homemade Pet Biscuits
With the help of these adorable dog treat cookie cutters, you can know exactly what your pup is consuming when they earn a reward.
Have you ever dreamt of making your own dog treats? There are plenty of recipes online, often including healthy ingredients like peanut butter and pumpkin. And you can make them just as cute as the store-bought versions with the help of dog treat cookie cutters. These products come in all sorts of shapes and sizes, such as bone outlines, puppy faces, and paw prints. Read on to discover some of our best picks from today’s dog treat cookie cutter market.
Best Dog Treat Cookie Cutters to Consider
When you first start looking into dog treat cookie cutters, it may be helpful to consider the recipe you’re thinking of working with. Some recipes have thick batter that rolls out into dough, while others need to be poured into and baked in molds. Look at the requested bakeware of your chosen recipe to see if you can use dog treat cookie cutters in the first place.
Next, consider the quality of the cookie cutters you like best. No matter how cute something is, you don’t want it to break mere months into use. Choose a durable product, preferably made of stainless steel, thick plastic, or silicone.
And last but not least, look at all of the cracks and crevices of your chosen product. Will it be difficult to clean? Will you need to purchase a special scrub brush to reach the tricker corners? Is it dishwasher-safe? A little extra effort is okay, especially if you love the cookie cutters, but it’s best to be prepared than to end up with messy molds after your first baking session.
Overall, dog treat cookie cutters are fairly simple but there are still a few points to consider before making your purchase. If you walk through these questions and feel confident in your answers, we believe you’ll be more than happy with the product you choose.
Easy-press dog treat cookie cutters
These cute cookie cutters come in the perfect shapes for dog treats. They have plastic covers to protect your hands while you press through thick dough. The variety in sizes allows you to create training treats and larger rewards. Being made of stainless steel, each piece is durable, long-lasting, and rust-resistant. They can be used for a variety of purposes outside of treat dough, too — think veggie bites, cheese shapes, fun sandwiches, and more.
Pros:
- Affordable
- Good variety of designs
- Creates clean cuts
- Safe for use with kids
Cons:
- Not dishwasher safe
Detailed dog treat cookie cutters
These adorable cookie cutters can help you create treats in the shapes of pups. Intricate embossing allows various fur textures and sweet little faces to appear on your baked goods. Each cookie cutter has two pieces, so you can cut thick dough and still leave designs on top. Choose from three different cartoon styles to suit your preferences. Make homemade dog treats, birthday cookies for dog-loving kids, and so much more.
Pros:
- Fair price point
- Easy to rinse clean
- Embossments are optional
- Several popular breeds represented
Cons:
- It takes more time to line up the pieces compared to plunger-style cutters
Tiny dog treat cookie cutters
These itty-bitty dog treat cookie cutters make excellent training treats or rewards for pets who need to watch their caloric intake. They’re also simply fun — and you can feed your pet more of them than you would larger biscuits. Sizes range from around 1.5” to 1.75”. The cutters come in a cute tin for gifting or safe-keeping. They’ll even arrive with a dog biscuit recipe so you can put them to use right away.
Pros:
- Made of durable tinplated steel
- Nice variety of shapes
- Curved edge on top for pain-free pressing
- Could make a great gift for the dog-lovers in your life
Cons:
- These will last longer if they are not placed in the dishwasher
Classic dog bone cookie cutters
These affordable and simple dog bone cookie cutters are perfect for making classic dog treats. The three-pack only costs a few dollars, and it comes with bones in three sizes to suit your pup’s needs. Each cutter is made of stainless steel for durability and longevity. The simple design is easy to clean, since it doesn’t have as many small crevices as other styles. They can also cut cookies for humans, as well as fruit, sandwich bites, and more.
Pros:
- Low price
- Sizes range from about 2” to about 5”
- Made with food-grade materials
- Also fun for crafting
Cons:
- May bend easily, but the material easily bends back into place
All-recipe dog bone cookie cutters and molds
This set includes everything you need to make any dog treat recipe you find online. First, it comes with cookie cutters as shown above. These are bone-shaped to represent traditional dog biscuits. The set also comes with silicone mods for recipes with thinner dough. The molds are safe for use in the oven and dishwasher. And since they’re made of food-grade materials, they can be used for human snacks just as well as pup treats.
Pros:
- Great value for the price
- Provides more cooking options
- Silicone molds leave embossed designs
- Safe for cooking with kids
Cons:
- Not available as single items — only as a set with both silicone molds and steel cookie cutters
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find dog treat recipes?
Simply search “homemade dog treats” and choose from the many hundreds of options that show up. Here is a simple recipe that works well with the style of cookie cutters we’ve gathered:
Ingredients: 1 cup peanut butter, 1 egg, 1 cup water, 2.5 cups whole wheat flour.
Instructions: Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Combine all ingredients well. Roll out dough to about 1/2” thick and press shapes. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper, place the treats on the tray, and bake for 18-20 minutes or until golden-brown.
Is it healthier to make your own dog treats?
Most dog treat recipes online are fairly healthy. They also give you the benefit of knowing exactly what your dog is consuming, which some pet parents appreciate. However, there is nothing wrong with feeding store-bought treats as well. Some of our favorite treats on Amazon include these hypoallergenic options. We also love feeding doggy ice cream and chew sticks.
How long do homemade dog treats last after baking?
If refrigerated or frozen in an airtight container, these treats can last several months. If kept out, they should be consumed within a few days.
About the Author
Why Trust Us
DogTime is a leading resource for dog owners & pet lovers. Our goal is to give every dog & pet a happy, healthy home by providing the best advice to owners.